Ares Armor Writes Hilarious Letter to ATF in Crayon
In an open letter to the BATFE, Dimitrios Karras of Ares Armor wrote a letter thanking them for defining what a weapon is, what a receiver is, and excoriates them on mistakes they made in their recently published 2015-01 ruling. The entire letter is published below along with the crayon version that is sure to be a big hit in the pro liberty community.
The Honorable B. Todd Jones
Director Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives
99 New York Avenue, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20226
Dear Director Jones,
I have read ATF Rul. 2015-1 which was intended to clarify your position on several issues. I would like to thank you for your indirect admission that a firearm receiver is not a âreceiverâ, as defined by the GCA of 1968, until it can house all of the necessary parts that it is intended to house. I know this was not your intent. However, your words are very clear.
PART 1. Statements and Admissions
- ) A âframe or receiverâ and a âweaponâ, are separately and uniquely defined in the GCA of 1968.
You correctly state on page 2 the following,
Section 921(a)(3), defines a âfirearm,â in relevant part, as both a âweapon ⊠which will or is designed to or may readily be converted to expel a projectile by the action of an explosiveâ (921(a)(3)(A)), and the âframe or receiver of any such weaponâ
You correctly observe that both a âweaponâ and the âframe or receiverâ of a weapon are defined separately in the GCA. Thank you for this admission!
- ) The âmay readily be convertedâ phrase only applies to âweaponâ and not to âreceiverâ.
As can be seen by your admission, these are defined separately. Therefore, you are also admitting that âmay readily be convertedâ applies only to âweaponâ and not to âframe or receiverâ. Thank you for this admission!
- ) The meaning of the word âmanufactureâ is âto make into a product suitable for use.â
On page 3 you correctly quote the Broughman Case,
See Broughman at 675 (â[T]he plain and ordinary meaning of the word âmanufactureâ is âto make into a product suitable for use.ââ (quoting Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary (2010))âŠ
You love to quote court cases that agree with you and ignore ones that donât agree. However, thank you for this admission!
- ) An object that is NOT suitable for use as a âreceiverâ is NOT classified as a âreceiverâ.
On page 2 and 3 you state the following,
ââŠit generally requires substantial additional machining before it can accommodate fire control components such as a trigger, hammer, or searâŠâ
ââŠincapable of being assembled into a weaponâŠâ
And my personal favorite quote on page 3,
âATF Ruling 2010-10 assumes that a licensed dealer-gunsmiths would perform certain activities on articles ALREADY classified as frames or receivers (i.e., no machining or other processes required to allow it to be used to assemble a weapon)⊠*emphasis added
Here, you have very clearly stated that an item that requires âmachining or other processesâ before it is suitable for use in assembling a weapon would not ALREADY be classified as a frame or receiver. THANK YOU FOR THIS GIGANTIC ADMISSION!
- ) Indexing marks DO NOT make a random object into a âreceiverâ.
On page 3, you incorrectly and in pompous contempt of the Court make the following statement,
Although such an article may be classified as a âreceiverâ when it is indexedâŠ
As you are fully aware, this is direct conflict with UNITED STATES v. PRINCE. The ATF has already lost this argument in Federal Court. I have mentioned this case in previous communication with you. It is fully on record that you are aware of this case and its implications. Your choice to ignore this case is despicable at best.
âThe court finds that the metal flat shipped to Prince is not a firearm. The court carefully considered the expert testimony of Agent Adam Galbraith, and reviewed the material submitted by the government concerning ATF opinions. However, the court simply does not believe that a flat piece of metal with laser perforations and holes constitutes a âreceiver,â i.e., a âfirearm.â Rather, the flat piece of metal is somewhat akin to a piece of paper with lines drawn on it as a guide to make a paper airplane. Although making the paper airplane might be the intended use, it is not an airplane until it is properly folded. Until that time, it is a patterned piece of paper. Simply put, this court has no evidentiary or legal basis for holding that a flat piece of metal with laser perforations and some holes constitutes, ultimately, a âfirearm.ââ
http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-10th-circuit/1506044.html
PART 2. The Lunacy Of Your Conclusions
On pages 4 and 5 you state the following,
However, when a licensed gunsmith takes in a frame or receiver to perform machining or other manufacturing process, that gunsmith âdistributesâ a firearm to the customer upon return because that manufacturing activity results in the making of a different âframe or receiverâ and also a âweaponâŠwhich will or is designed to or may readily be converted to expel a projectileâ âboth defined separately as a âfirearmâ under the GCA.
You somehow confusingly conclude that even though both terms are defined separately, a âreceiverâ is a âweaponâŠwhich will or is designed to or may readily be converted to expel a projectileâ
Let me ask one simple question⊠If a âreceiverâ is a âweaponâ, why are they defined separately and uniquely in the GCA as firearms?
A âreceiverâ by itself cannot be âreadily converted to expel a projectileâ as the receiver by itself lacks the necessary parts. I would love to hand you a receiver and ask you to readily convert it into a weapon. Perhaps you would do that hand waiving Jedi-Mind trick thing you did to Congress when you were asked about why you raided my business!
A receiver is PART of a weapon. A receiver is NOT a weapon by itself, as it is clearly defined separately and uniquely in the GCA per your own admission.
Riddle me this one Batman⊠If a âreceiverâ is a âweaponâ then it must have an individual part of itself that is a âreceiverâ, which would be classified separately from it as a âfirearmâ⊠So where exactly is it that I can buy this mysterious âreceiver, of a receiver, of a receiver, of a receiverâ that you refer to?
PART 3. The Common Sense Conclusion Based On Your Statements.
- ) A âframe or receiverâ and a âweaponâ, are separately and uniquely defined in the GCA of 1968.
- ) The âmay readily be convertedâ phrase only applies to âweaponâ and not to âreceiverâ.
- ) The meaning of the word âmanufactureâ is âto make into a product suitable for use.â
- ) An object that is NOT suitable for use as a âreceiverâ is NOT classified as a âreceiverâ.
- ) Indexing marks DO NOT make a random object into a âreceiverâ.
I conclude, based off of your statements, that one cannot be charged with a crime of âmanufacturingâ (make into a product suitable for use) an AR âreceiverâ ( â[t]hat part of a firearm which provides housing for the hammer, bolt or breechblock, and firing mechanism, and which is usually threaded at its forward portion to receive the barrel.â) if that âreceiverâ does not provide housing for any of the intended mechanisms.
I would like to thank you for your clarification that NOT drilling the through holes for the fire-control group (safety selector, trigger pin, and hammer pin) would be sufficient to have NOT manufactured a âreceiverâ.
Just to sink your own words in one more time, I will provide you with your quote from page 3 again,
âATF Ruling 2010-10 assumes that a licensed dealer-gunsmiths would perform certain activities on articles ALREADY classified as frames or receivers (i.e., no machining or other processes required to allow it to be used to assemble a weapon)⊠*emphasis added
I expect that you will issue a letter in response to this stating that one can manufacture a 99% receiver (missing only the 3 holes for the fire control group) and not be charged with âmanufacturing a âfirearmââ.
I salute you on your efforts of making the hobby of building firearms at home easier!
To make things easier for you and your agents to understand, I have commissioned these concepts to be drawn in crayon. I have attached this drawing to this letter. You are welcome.
You block, you stone, you worse than senseless thing,
Dimitrios Karras
One of Your Restless Villagers
Semper Fi!



